Procharge or supercharge? more reliable? Faster?

Printable Version

Corvette Forums >> Corvette Models >> Corvette C5 Forum >> Procharge or supercharge? more reliable? Faster?

Page: [1] 2   next >   >>

Login Message << Older Topic   Newer Topic >>

Procharge or supercharge? more reliable? Faster? - 9/9/2008 12:49:02 PM    y2001c5   Posts: 15 Joined: 7/10/2008 Status: offline which is the best way to boost the c5? the Safest? and the most powerfull? dose anybody know of anyone that has a used procharged or supercharged system that they are selling for the c5? _____________________________ 2001 yellow c5 slp loudmouth catback blackwing intake sp500 ccw racing wheels Post #: 1

RE: Procharge or supercharge? more reliable? Faster? - 9/9/2008 3:13:51 PM    Lee Willis   Posts: 1991 Joined: 7/27/2005 Status: offline A Procharger is a supercharger, a centrifugal type like the Vortech, as oppsed to a screw/Roots type like the Eaton/Magnusen or the Kenny Bell.  I''''ve had both on a ''''vette.  I had the Magnusen on an otherwise stock ''''02 ZO6, and it was by far the better set up: a very sweet kit and fit well and ran well from day one, with gobs of low end torque, excellent throttle response, and a wonderful howl at full throttle.  You do have to replace your hood with a new one with a bulge to clear the Maggie, though, and, with paint, that will run a couple of grand, making the Maggie more expensive (on the other hand the hood looks very good. I had a Procharger D1SC later on, a considerably higher output than the P that you normally put on anear stock ''''vette: I had a built C5R (essentially an early LS7, before there were LS7s) installed that made about 515 RWHP and I wanted more.  The biggest maggie then would not blow enough air (they have a slightly larger one now but I''''m not sure it does either).  The Procharger was an okay unit but I had lots of minor problems I eventually sorted out it did not provide the throttle response or the low end torque boost of the Maggie (but then the 7-liter C5R didn''''t need it), but it sure blew a lot of air at high RPM.   If you can afford the hood, go with the Maggie. _____________________________ 2007 Aston Martin Vantage Prodrive Lincoln MKZ "Grandfather car" ''98 Z28 with iron LS 408, NOS, tricks, street driven mid 9s (sold to my youngest son for $1, Aug 28, ''07) ''02 SCd 427 cid ZO6, 704 RWHP, sold Aug. 28, ''07 (in reply to y2001c5) Post #: 2

RE: Procharge or supercharge? more reliable? Faster? - 9/9/2008 8:35:42 PM    Dave01 Posts: 690 Joined: 9/24/2005 Status: offline Lee, the main reason why I would go Vortech is the hood. Certain colors are very difficult to match perfectly (like my Mag Red II with its yellow-tinted clearcoat) and I surely would NOT want to spend the bucks to have my whole car painted. If you are going to have an old, faded car repainted, then the new hood would make sense if it meant getting a Maggie. However I hear that having 3.90s and a Vortech is a real blast with sticky enough rubber. That''d be my choice with 490 RWHP as the result. _____________________________ 2001 MN6 Coupe, all options Halltech Stinger-R intake w/cold air mod - see www.conceptualpolymer.com (Corvette Corner) BPP shifter w/glass elegance shift knob Borla Stinger quad round exhaust Goodyear GSD3s (in reply to y2001c5) Post #: 3

RE: Procharge or supercharge? more reliable? Faster? - 9/10/2008 11:19:59 AM    Lee Willis   Posts: 1991 Joined: 7/27/2005 Status: offline Makes sense if you like it that combination.  I spent $2200 on top of the cost of the hood just on the respray on my vette, and I loved the look of the hood bulge.  3.90 gears represent a 10+% increase in revs at every speed, which is too much for me, I like to let torque handle the issues off the line and was considered going to a 3:15 gear on mine: I though the engie would pull it.  3.90s and a Vortech: I''d minitub the rear wheel wells and get 345 drag radials, antying else won''t put the power to the ground. _____________________________ 2007 Aston Martin Vantage Prodrive Lincoln MKZ "Grandfather car" ''98 Z28 with iron LS 408, NOS, tricks, street driven mid 9s (sold to my youngest son for $1, Aug 28, ''07) ''02 SCd 427 cid ZO6, 704 RWHP, sold Aug. 28, ''07 (in reply to Dave01) Post #: 4

RE: Procharge or supercharge? more reliable? Faster? - 9/10/2008 5:50:44 PM    y2001c5   Posts: 15 Joined: 7/10/2008 Status: offline ok well i was about to jump on the procharger but i guess i should go roots type then? _____________________________ 2001 yellow c5 slp loudmouth catback blackwing intake sp500 ccw racing wheels (in reply to Lee Willis) Post #: 5

RE: Procharge or supercharge? more reliable? Faster? - 9/10/2008 8:23:30 PM    Dave01 Posts: 690 Joined: 9/24/2005 Status: offline I have 3.42s, so with standard-width tires, that ratio should be fine with 490 RWHP. y2001c5, If I were you, I''d find out how easy or hard it is to match new hood paint to the rest of your car before getting a roots-type. Here in San Diego, there are many happy ProCharger and Vortech owners running around. I guess it all depends upon your money situation as well. _____________________________ 2001 MN6 Coupe, all options Halltech Stinger-R intake w/cold air mod - see www.conceptualpolymer.com (Corvette Corner) BPP shifter w/glass elegance shift knob Borla Stinger quad round exhaust Goodyear GSD3s (in reply to y2001c5) Post #: 6

RE: Procharge or supercharge? more reliable? Faster? - 9/11/2008 5:02:05 AM    maierar   Posts: 22 Joined: 7/2/2007 Status: offline Have you considered turbocharging rather than supercharging? Pros outweigh the cons imo. Whichever you decide, remember to research your installer as carefully as what you are installing. (in reply to Dave01) Post #: 7

RE: Procharge or supercharge? more reliable? Faster? - 9/11/2008 11:20:00 AM    Lee Willis   Posts: 1991 Joined: 7/27/2005 Status: offline The best route is to set your goals down on paper - how much power, etc., then carefully research the cost and issues associated with each option, screw type (Maggies are slightly different than a true roots type).  I do think, for day to day fun operation on the street the Maggie is great: it''s a well developed no-hassle kit, it makes as much power at the top as you can reliably put through a stock LS1 or LS3 bottom end, it has no lag or time to build up like turbos and centrifugal SCrs, and it produces more torque lower down, which makes for a very relaxed, powerful feeling car in daily driving.  But the Maggie may end up looking to cost you an extra $2K for the hood, paint, etc., which is something to consider, because Vortech and procharger kits do work well. So, check out everything and then make your decision based on what you want, what you''ll get, and price.  _____________________________ 2007 Aston Martin Vantage Prodrive Lincoln MKZ "Grandfather car" ''98 Z28 with iron LS 408, NOS, tricks, street driven mid 9s (sold to my youngest son for $1, Aug 28, ''07) ''02 SCd 427 cid ZO6, 704 RWHP, sold Aug. 28, ''07 (in reply to maierar) Post #: 8

RE: Procharge or supercharge? more reliable? Faster? - 9/11/2008 4:30:43 PM    y2001c5   Posts: 15 Joined: 7/10/2008 Status: offline thats true maierar i have the choice of twin turbo however i herd that there are issues with the systems such as overheating and reliability but they produce the most power _____________________________ 2001 yellow c5 slp loudmouth catback blackwing intake sp500 ccw racing wheels (in reply to Lee Willis) Post #: 9

RE: Procharge or supercharge? more reliable? Faster? - 9/11/2008 6:09:16 PM    Lee Willis   Posts: 1991 Joined: 7/27/2005 Status: offline Any system, turbos, Procharger, Vortech, Magnusen, will push a LS1, LS6, or LS2 to around 475-490 RWHP.  That is all the stock engine and drive train will handle: I know, I''ve seen three stock short blocks come apart when the boost was turned up to get 510-525.  The fact that turbos might produce more power is irrelevant unless you are going to build up a really good bottom end and use heavy duty everything. _____________________________ 2007 Aston Martin Vantage Prodrive Lincoln MKZ "Grandfather car" ''98 Z28 with iron LS 408, NOS, tricks, street driven mid 9s (sold to my youngest son for $1, Aug 28, ''07) ''02 SCd 427 cid ZO6, 704 RWHP, sold Aug. 28, ''07 (in reply to y2001c5) Post #: 10

Today's Posts
Most Active Topics
Make A Donation
Forum Rules & FAQ
RSS Feeds

Corvette Prices

Corvette
Corvette Z06
Corvette History

Top 10 Posters
c3 starship 4814 blueshark 2180 topspeed 2092 lee willis 1991 mech259 1760 pay2play 1533 cwb 1508 corvette kin 1162 73shark 1130 pg 1066

New Vendors
AMSOIL - Performance Oil Technology